Download
0 / 0

Her father is forcing her to attend gatherings in which there are innovations (bid’ah). How should she behave with him?

Question: 97800

My father is forcing me (19), my brother (15) and my sister (11) to go to a place where bidah is practised and if i dont go my dad will find out. at that place they sometimes miss prayers, they sing, they recite the 99names of Allaah together in groups rocking back and forth(i never knew the companions to do this?!), and add extras at the end of surah-tul fatihah. Im a new muslim and i dont want to go astray like some people have, i want to go strictly according to the sunnnah of our prophet (pbuh). However, if i dont go, i fear i would get kicked our of my house for disobeying my father, i would have no where to go, but i was also told the hadith of where innovation is present we should leave. i dont know what to do, i would rather tell my dad that im not going and get thrown out cos i fear Allaah, but it would be cutting ties of kinship which is a great sin!….if i go, what about my brother and my sister, how would i rescue them from this innovation, and where would i go to? am i allowed to leave my house and live with another sister or do i need a mehram? please help me.

Praise be to Allah, and peace and blessings be upon the Messenger of Allah and his family.

Firstly: 

When reading this letter,
although we feel sad about what is mentioned in it, we feel happy when we
read of this sister’s common sense, intelligence and good following of the
Sunnah, and that she is upset at the presence of bid’ah and she is afraid of
falling into sin by disobeying her father who is telling her to go to the
place where these innovations are practised. She is also thinking of leaving
home but she is worried about her brother and sister and is afraid that she
will be going against sharee’ah if she does not have a mahram with her. All
of this, and she is a new Muslim. We ask Allaah by His names and attributes
to make her and her siblings steadfast in adhering to the truth, and guide
her family to follow the Sunnah. 

Secondly: 

We say to the sister who is
asking this question: 

1.Undoubtedly attending these
gatherings with their innovations and sins is regarded as something that is
contrary to sharee’ah. Those innovators are not content with merely
mentioning the names of Allaah in song and dance, rather they had added
other sins, namely failing to offer the prayers on time. This indicates that
their claim that they are worshipping Allaah and drawing close to Him is
false. If they were sincere in their desire to draw close to Him, they would
worship in the ways that He has prescribed, and they would not miss the
prayer, which is the greatest practical pillar of Islam. The texts of the
Qur’aan and Sunnah issue stern warnings to those who do not offer the prayer
on time and those who neglect the prayer.

2.It is well known in sharee’ah
that attending such gatherings incurs a great deal of sin and leads to many
negative consequences, but there may be some interest to be served by
delaying one’s refusal to go, because that delay may bring benefits and ward
off harms.

3.One of the interests served by
your continuing to go now is taking care of your brother and sister and
making sure that there is someone with them who can guide them and explain
to them what is wrong with these actions. Another interest that will be
served is making sure that your non-attendance will not lead to your father
throwing you out of the house, which is something that would lead to many
evils and bad consequences, the extent of which no one knows but Allaah,
especially in the country where you live and even in other countries.

4.We think that you could
continue to go, but go as little as you can, and make up some excuses that
will be acceptable to your father for not going, as well as trying hard to
bring in wise people of Ahl al-Sunnah who can explain the truth to your
father.

5.A person such as you will not
be deceived, in sha Allaah, by what these ignorant innovators are doing.
Neverthless we advise you to protect your faith by doing acts of worship and
increasing your knowledge by reading and studying the books of Ahl
al-Sunnah. This will be beneficial for you. And ask trustworthy people of
Ahl al-Sunnah about everything that is not clear to you, and remember that
you have to keep advising and teaching and guiding your siblings. You should
also try to influence some of the other girls who attend these gatherings
and call them to the truth and the right path.

6.If you go there, we advise you
to avoid these gatherings as much as you can, by sitting with the women in a
separate room far away from these innovations and deviations. Be the last to
enter and the first to leave, as much as you can.

7.We advise you to sit with your
father and discuss with him what he is telling you to do, and to try to
convince him about these innovators. You are at an age where you can do that
with him. And you have enough knowledge to convince him in sha Allaah.

8.Always pray for your father and
advise him, and treat him well all the time, for “there is no kindness in a
thing but it adorns it, and it is not taken away from a thing but it makes
it defective” as the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon
him) said.

We ask Allaah to help you
to do that which He loves and which pleases Him, and to make you steadfast
in adhering to the truth, and to guide your father to the truth. 

And Allaah is the Source of
strength.

Source

Islam Q&A

Was this answer helpful?

at email

Our newsletter

To join our newsletter please add your email below

phone

IslamQA App

For a quick access to our content and offline browsing

download iosdownload android